The History of Trading Card Games (TCG): From Magic: The Gathering to Hearthstone and Marvel Snap
From Magic: The Gathering in 1993 through the Pokémon TCG, Yu-Gi-Oh!, and digital TCGs like Magic Online, Hearthstone, Shadowverse, and Marvel Snap, plus design principles such as booster packs, rarity, ban lists, and rotation, and TCG culture in Korea.
A trading card game (TCG) packs three activities into one box: collect cards, build your own deck, and compete against an opponent. Unlike playing cards or hwatu, where everyone uses the same deck, every TCG player owns a different set of cards, and that difference is the strategy.
In this post, we follow the genre from the moment Magic: The Gathering created it in 1993, through Pokémon and Yu-Gi-Oh! turning it into children's culture, to digital TCGs such as Magic Online, Hearthstone, and Marvel Snap. In the second half we look at design principles like booster packs and rarity, the secondary market, ban lists and rotation, and take a look at TCG culture in Korea.
The difference between deck-building games (Dominion, Slay the Spire, and so on) and TCGs is covered separately in What Are Card and Deck-Building Games?, so we won't go deep into it here.
What Is a TCG?
Trading card games are also called collectible card games (CCGs). A game counts as a TCG when it has these three features.
- Randomized sales: Cards are sold in booster packs, and you don't know which cards are inside.
- Personal deck construction: Players build a deck from the cards they own, following the game's rules, and bring it to a match.
- Trading: Swapping spare cards with other people is part of the game.
That is why "trading" is in the name. Buying, swapping, and collecting cards continues outside the game itself, so a TCG is less a single board game than a hobby culture.
1993: The Birth of Magic: The Gathering
The TCG genre began with one person's design. In the early 1990s, American mathematician Richard Garfield pitched a board game to Peter Adkison of a small company called Wizards of the Coast. Adkison asked instead for "a game that is quick to play and easy to carry," and Garfield came up with a card game. The result was Magic: The Gathering, released in August 1993.
Magic's core inventions were three.
- Each player brings a different deck. It's the same game, but everyone uses different cards, so every match creates a new situation.
- Cards are sold in random booster packs. Not knowing what you'll get makes opening packs exciting, and rare cards naturally become objects of trade.
- The mana system. Playing land cards to gather resources and spending them on spells and creatures became the basic framework for almost every TCG that followed.
Magic was far more popular than expected right from launch, and Wizards of the Coast was acquired by Hasbro in 1999 and still makes Magic today. After Magic, Garfield went on to design Netrunner (1996), King of Tokyo (2011), and Valve's digital TCG Artifact (2018), among others.
Pokémon in 1996, Yu-Gi-Oh! in 1999: Into Children's Hands
Where Magic leaned toward older teens and adults, two games from Japan brought TCGs into children's culture.
The Pokémon Trading Card Game was released in Japan in October 1996 by Media Factory. The Game Boy game Pocket Monsters had come out in February of the same year, so the cards arrived before the game's popularity had even cooled. In 1999, Wizards of the Coast published the English edition and set off a craze in North America, and since 2003 The Pokémon Company has published the game itself. The Pokémon TCG is a rare case where the original's appeal of "collecting Pokémon" overlaps exactly with the TCG appeal of "collecting cards."
The Yu-Gi-Oh! Official Card Game (OCG) was released by Konami in Japan in February 1999. It turned the card game from Kazuki Takahashi's manga Yu-Gi-Oh! (serialized in Weekly Shonen Jump from 1996) into a real product. Being able to play the very cards the protagonist uses in the manga and anime resonated strongly with children. In 2011, Yu-Gi-Oh! was listed in Guinness World Records as the best-selling TCG in the world.
The three games each broadened TCGs in a different direction.
| Game | First release | Company | Characteristics |
|---|---|---|---|
| Magic: The Gathering | 1993 (US) | Wizards of the Coast | Genre prototype, mana system, adult hobby |
| Pokémon TCG | 1996 (Japan) | Media Factory → The Pokémon Company | Based on a video game, collection-focused, gateway for children |
| Yu-Gi-Oh! OCG | 1999 (Japan) | Konami | Based on a manga, fast-paced, best-selling in the world |
Digital TCGs: From Magic Online to Marvel Snap
TCGs began on paper, but in the 2000s they started moving to digital.
Magic: The Gathering Online (2002) was a PC version of Magic made by Wizards of the Coast itself. It carried over the rules and cards of paper Magic as they were, and digital cards could be bought and sold like physical ones. But the rules were complex and the interface was hard, so it remained a service for existing Magic players.
The real turning point was Hearthstone, released by Blizzard in March 2014. Hearthstone wasn't a port of paper cards; it was designed for digital from the start. It removed the rules for interrupting the opponent's turn so only one person has to think at a time, made mana grow automatically by one each turn with no land cards, and put randomness into card effects that would be impossible on paper. It was free to start and ran on mobile. In November 2018, Blizzard announced that Hearthstone had passed 100 million players in total.
After Hearthstone, digital TCGs came one after another.
- Shadowverse (2016): A Japanese digital TCG by Cygames, known for its anime-style art and "Evolve" system. It was especially popular in Japan and Korea.
- Gwent (2018): CD Projekt Red's standalone version of the minigame from The Witcher 3.
- Artifact (2018): A Dota 2 TCG made by Valve together with Richard Garfield. Its complex rules, with three battlefields handled at once, and a structure where cards were bought and sold for money were not well received, and it declined quickly.
- Magic: The Gathering Arena (full release 2019): A new digital Magic that learned from Magic Online's difficulty and was built to be light like Hearthstone. It is now Magic's main digital platform.
- Legends of Runeterra (2020): Riot Games' TCG set in the League of Legends universe.
- Yu-Gi-Oh! Master Duel (2022): Konami's digital version that carries over the OCG rules almost unchanged.
- Marvel Snap (2022): Made by Second Dinner, founded by Ben Brode, Hearthstone's first game director. A match ends in about 3 minutes, decks are 12 cards, and there are only 6 turns. The "snap" rule for raising the stakes and the removal of card trading showed how far a TCG could be trimmed down for the mobile era.
- Pokémon TCG Pocket (2024): A mobile game by The Pokémon Company and DeNA that puts the fun of opening and collecting cards first and greatly simplifies the battle rules.
The trend of digital TCGs in one line is "shorter, easier, more often." A game of Magic Online took tens of minutes; a game of Marvel Snap takes 3.
Booster Packs and Rarity: Designing the Thrill of Opening
A TCG's economy begins with the booster pack. Magic's early boosters held 15 cards, with cards of different rarities mixed in at set ratios.
- Common: The most plentiful cards. The backbone of a deck.
- Uncommon: Somewhat scarcer cards.
- Rare: About one per pack, with powerful or unusual effects.
- Mythic Rare: The highest tier, added by Magic in 2008.
The names differ from game to game, like holographic cards in Pokémon or Ultra Rare and Secret Rare in Yu-Gi-Oh!, but the principle is the same. Rarity plays two roles. One is the anticipation of opening. Every pack brings "what will I get this time?", the same psychology as gacha. The other is as a design tool. Putting strong, complex cards at rare keeps the commons that beginners meet most often simple, which makes the game easier to learn.
Rarity draws criticism too. If strong cards cluster at rare, people who spend more money gain an advantage. Magic partly solved this with Limited play. In Draft and Sealed events, where you build a deck only from packs opened on the spot, everyone starts under the same conditions.
The Secondary Market: Cards Become Assets
TCG cards are things you use and, at the same time, things that are traded. What began as swaps between players became a market through card shops and online marketplaces, and this is called the secondary market.
The most famous card in Magic is Black Lotus, from the first set in 1993. Its effect is simple, three free mana, but it was so strong that it was banned early, and because the first print run was small, a copy in good condition now sells at auction for millions of dollars as a collectible. On the Pokémon side, the Pikachu Illustrator card, made in tiny numbers as a prize for an illustration contest in 1998, holds the Guinness World Record as the most expensive Pokémon card.
The existence of a secondary market also affects game design. In 1996, Wizards of the Coast created the Reserved List, promising never to reprint certain early cards. It was meant to protect card values, but it is still debated today because it makes old cards hard for new players to obtain. Digital TCGs solved this problem in an entirely different way. Hearthstone and Marvel Snap did away with card trading altogether, and Magic Arena uses a wildcard system that converts spare cards into other cards.
Ban Lists and Rotation: Keeping a Living Game Alive
A TCG releases hundreds of new cards every few months. As cards pile up, combinations the designers never anticipated appear, and eventually one deck wins every match. Two mechanisms prevent this.
A ban list (forbidden and limited list) keeps problem cards out of tournament play. Magic bans or restricts to one copy, in most formats, the nine powerful early cards including Black Lotus known as the Power Nine. Yu-Gi-Oh! regularly updates its Forbidden & Limited List, dividing cards into Forbidden (0 copies), Limited (1), and Semi-Limited (2). Digital TCGs go a step further and change the numbers on the cards themselves. Hearthstone patches the attack or cost of overly strong cards, something impossible with paper.
Rotation removes older cards from the main competitive format. Magic created the Standard format in 1995, using only cards from the last few years, and in April 2016 Hearthstone split into Standard, on the same principle, and Wild, which allows every card. Rotation has three effects.
- New players have fewer cards to catch up on.
- Old, strong cards leave, so the game environment refreshes periodically.
- From the company's point of view, it creates a reason to keep buying new cards.
Because of that third reason, rotation always draws player complaints. So most TCGs also keep formats without rotation (Magic's Modern and Legacy, Hearthstone's Wild).
TCG Culture in Korea
In Korea, TCGs spread widely among children and teenagers in the early 2000s through the Korean edition of Yu-Gi-Oh!. With the anime airing on TV, it was common to buy Yu-Gi-Oh! cards at stationery stores and card shops and duel at school and around the neighborhood. The Korean edition of the Pokémon TCG has also been released steadily since, and it drew big attention once again in 2022 alongside the Pokémon bread craze.
Magic: The Gathering does have Korean-language cards, but in Korea it has remained a relatively niche adult hobby. Digital TCGs, on the other hand, were especially strong in Korea. After its 2014 launch, Hearthstone became very popular through PC bangs and YouTube and streaming platforms, and Korean players consistently did well at world championships. Shadowverse also built a solid fan base through its Korean service.
Recently, TCGs made by Korean companies have appeared as well. In 2024, Devsisters released Cookie Run: Braverse, a paper TCG set in the Cookie Run universe, and is building a domestic card-shop and tournament culture around it. Collecting cards, small tournaments held at card shops, and digital TCGs played online are all taking root in Korea together.
Why TCGs Have Lasted More Than 30 Years
Countless TCGs have come and gone since Magic in 1993, but the genre itself has never gone dark. New paper TCGs keep arriving, such as Flesh and Blood in 2019, Bandai's One Piece Card Game in 2022, and Ravensburger's Disney Lorcana in 2023.
The reasons come down to these.
- Collecting: The anticipation of opening a pack and the satisfaction of completing a collection.
- Creating: The fun of building your own deck from thousands of cards. This is where TCGs come closest to deck-building games.
- Competing: The tension of facing another person under the same rules.
- Community: Relationships that continue outside the game, through trading, shop tournaments, and online discussion.
Because all four fit inside a single card, TCGs keep coming back in new forms even as the medium shifts from paper to screen.